Who was the best Sonic Sidekick Tails Or Knuckles?

[RS Chao]

Oh yeah, also the fact that Tails can make these death machines and stuff when necessary is nice. XD

[Shade the Hedgehog]

KNUCKLES!!!!!!

[Nano]

OMG! 43 votes for tails XD

tails because he helps out more and knuckles just loses the emeralds in mostly every game :P

@ shade: don't spam.

[Rosetiger]

tails, because he actually acts as a sidekick, whereas knuckles just sort of flits in and out.

also tails can fly. and has a plane or two.

but knuckles has a flying island?! I want one.

[The Hyper Chao]

TAAAAIIIILS TAILS TAILS!!! Hes so cute ^+^

[Galaxina /499]

Tails, Knuckles has been stupid and tried to kill sonic sooo many times, tails is like a dog, loyal, follows you every where, Nice, Knuckles is like a .... well he's like a.... I don't know but it's something bad.
Tails Tails Tails I LOVE TAILS GO TAILS every one who said
TAILS thank you for agreeing with me oh and make sure you don't steal some of my very conspiracy words and I'm finally out of School YAY oh and if you want free pants go to ADULT SWIM.COM and enter the code

[Ravior]

I say Tails. He's my favorite character. He has a better personality. He can invent things for Sonic. He follows Sonic no matter what.

Pretty much what everyone else has said.

Anyway, Knuckles is one of my least favorite characters. He's a knucklehead, anyway.

[Blitz]

Although I like Knuckles better than Tails, I think Tails is a better sidekick to Sonic. Tails and Sonic seem to be better friends, and half the time Kunckles and Sonic are fighting, or Knuckles just randomly leaves.

[chaoswalker]

Tails, because of team work ability in Sonic 3. (Tails flying Sonic.)

[kdlove96]

tails he is all ways there 4 sonic and hes verey verey smart

[ZipoCXG]

I say Tails, he's not only cute, but is also very smart and tries his best to help with sonic.

EDIT: WOO!!!!! Imma Legendary Chaos Chao FINALLY!!!!!

[Holyfansia]

Tails because he is not that stubborn or hothead. Beside he is the cyber-tech one! His flight ability help Sonic a lot!
And Knuckles... He have to guard the Master Emerald. Knuckles is even stupid enough to belive what Eggman say.
say "WE SAY TAILS!"

[Lamby]

Woah there, be nice to the red grumpy guss. He's not stupid, he's gullible.

Edit: just noticed how far this has been bumped. Yikes.

[Hero Chao]

Tails
knuckles mostly is a rival for sonic